A brief, broad measure of six spiritual struggles: Initial validation of the six-item Religious and Spiritual Struggles Scale (RSS-6), comparisons with the new RSS-14-R, and demographic differences using a nationally representative sample from the United States.

Jul 1, 2026·
Julie J. Exline
,
Kenneth I. Pargament
Joshua B. Grubbs
Joshua B. Grubbs
,
Joshua A. Wilt
,
Ann M. Yali
· 0 min read
DOI
Abstract
Our aim was to provide initial validation for the six-item Religious and Spiritual Struggles Scale (RSS-6), which uses broad items to capture the six domains of the Religious and Spiritual Struggles Scale (Exline, Pargament, Grubbs, & Yali, 2014). We also introduced the Religious and Spiritual Struggles Scale–14–Revised (RSS-14-R), a minor revision of the Religious and Spiritual Struggles Scale–14 (RSS-14; Exline et al., 2023) that replaces an item on lack of meaning with one on questioning whether one’s life will make a difference in the world. We drew data from a nationally representative, longitudinal sample (N = 3,964) recruited through YouGov. Participants completed the RSS-14-R at baseline and the RSS-6 1 week later. They completed distress measures (depression, anxiety, loneliness) at baseline, 6 months, and 1 year. The RSS-6 related in expected ways to the RSS-14-R. On the RSS-6, 62% of participants endorsed some struggle (at least “a little bit”) in the past few weeks (ultimate meaning: 42%; moral: 41%; interpersonal: 31%; doubt: 29%; divine: 25%; demonic: 21%). Both the RSS-6 and RSS-14-R correlated positively with emotional distress and predicted sustained distress over time. Participants who were younger, reported some religious affiliation, and did not identify as White, cisgender, or heterosexual reported more spiritual struggle. These results provide initial validation for the RSS-6 and RSS-14-R. They echo prior work showing that spiritual struggles are widespread and linked with mental health, cross-sectionally and over time. The RSS-6 may work especially well as a screener, as its broad categories can capture spiritual struggles not mentioned in other abbreviated Religious and Spiritual Struggles Scale versions.
Type
Publication
Psychology of Religion and Spirituality
publications
Joshua B. Grubbs
Authors
Associate Professor of Psychology · Licensed Clinical Psychologist
Joshua Grubbs is an Associate Professor of Psychology at the University of New Mexico and an Investigator at the Center on Alcohol, Substance use, And Addictions (CASAA), where he directs the Behavioral Addictions And Associated Disorders (BAAAD) Lab. His research examines gambling and sports betting, compulsive sexual behavior, and alcohol use, with a focus on how social, moral, and policy contexts shape addictive behavior.